Our man Charles Thurston hosted a solar carport Q&A with Borrego Solar as part of his research into the topic for this month’s edition of pv magazine.
Here are a few extra insights that came in after the presses rolled.
Trevor Dawson, an industrial engineer asks: What factors are driving the growth of solar carports?
Borrego: I think solar carports are growing for a variety of reasons – public buy-in for solar is huge these days and I believe that confidence and the current political climate has many communities and businesses stepping up and becoming renewable energy leaders and climate activists themselves, to show off their long term, forward looking commitment to sustainability and a healthy population.
Carports are an easy option for many in urban and suburban areas as it puts their otherwise cost-sink parking lot or garage to work! Carports make economical sense and they are also huge statement pieces for the community – a rare branding or marketing opportunity with an attractive return on investment. A school, for example, can point to the carport and explain how it is investing in the long term for the school, students and community at large. That school becomes a point of pride in the community and a place parents want to send their kids.
Carports also create more value for the parking lot users, which our customers are interested in – the moment users arrive they have a better experience because of the improved safety and security from better LED lighting and protection from the brutal Californian sun or winter rains, the carports are also an aesthetic appeal to an otherwise uninteresting, boring, flat parking lot.
What is the economic argument supporting solar carports as a) retrofits; and b) new structures?
Both work. I don’t have a good grip on dollars but we get a lot of parking garage opportunities, new parking lots that were previously brownfields or just simply new structures added to pre-existing parking lots.
Are single or double-axis trackers a viable option for the carport market, and why?
Not yet, [it is an] interesting idea but I haven’t seen much precedence here – I’d be concerned about the O&M [operations and maintenance] cost, and also the image of large moving motors and tons of weight above humans seems like a more challenging sell. There has been movement towards bi-facial modules that could add 25% [energy] production [output].
What new designs or changes have you made in your offerings or business lately?
Snowy region carports are picking up steam – these are great because they keep cars warmer [and] cleaner and provide [a] safer and less icy approach for parking lot patrons. We almost built a carport out of wood for our [organic food] Clif Bar customer, as [it] wanted a solution more in tune with the environment and [its] wood-chip parking lot. I could see more jobs like this getting popular – BMW has made a few small scale carports like this – if we can develop a design at scale that is structurally sound and more environmentally conscious. That’s the point, right!
We recently moved from a tube steel structure to an i-beam or wide flange design – it’s nothing fancy but a more minimalist, industrial vibe which I think is a more timeless aesthetic and requires less drilling and penetration into the parking lot, which is always preferred.
Billy Christie, a regional engineering manager on the West Coast, said: “I believe the ubiquity of suitable locations for – as well as the high visibility of – commercial solar carports in relatively urban areas is one slightly more abstract reason for the growth of this subsection of solar PV.
“Carports do a good job of serving potential solar customers that lack the higher acreage required for ground mount systems as well as the large, clear roof space required for roof mounted systems. These ideal carport customers tend to share a common bond of having need for high capacity parking and large electrical demand – think airports, sports stadia, schools – and are almost always located near population centers due to the nature of their business. Because these are the ideal customers for solar carports, the structures are much more visible during most people’s day-to-day lives than commercial ground mount systems, which are more common in rural, less populated areas; and commercial rooftop systems, which are generally out of sight on top of flat-roofed buildings.
“I believe the common presence [of] carports has had an accelerating effect on growth by introducing potential future customers to the product during their everyday lives.”
This content is protected by copyright and may not be reused. If you want to cooperate with us and would like to reuse some of our content, please contact: editors@pv-magazine.com.
Baltimore county community college has solar canopies in their parking lots and they are a refuge from the hot sun in the summer and the snow in the winter. And you can charge your e-car!
Hi there, good article!
I am the CEO of Fresco Solar a California solar contractor that does rooftop and “carport” projects. I have parenthesized that word because in several recent projects we have literally had to remove the word entirely from our drawings and replace it with “solar canopies”. The reason is that “carport” triggers California Building Code issues as it generally refers to a structure adjacent to a residence! Just saying.
Sorry to hear the regulators are so narrow minded. I’ll call you next time I do a Solar Canopy story…
I really wish the big box stores would do this. As stated above it would be great to keep the car cooler in the summer and snow-free in the winter.
John: IKEA already have numerous solar car parks. I expect other companies will follow as the economics get better. To a first approximation, all car parks are alike, as roofs are not, so economies of scale are there for the taking. A leasing company could take over the project management and operations, if desired.
Engineered wood structures are a possibility with attractive aesthetics and imaging, and have been used by at least one Danish developer of highway EV charging stations (***cobe.dk/project/ultra-fast-charging-stations).
What do these structures cost?
Hello Charles, Good article! However, the comments from Borrego Solar about single or double-axis trackers not being a viable option for solar canopies is incorrect. They are absolutely viable. His statement: “I’d be concerned about the O&M [operations and maintenance] cost, and also the image of large moving motors and tons of weight above humans seems like a more challenging sell. ” is erroneous and misleading. Scarlet Solar offers a single -axis solar Tiltport that tracks the sun by tilting 30 degrees east and 30 degrees west, a 60-degree range, and is able to make the best of both the morning and the evening light. With a 60 degree range the Tiltport is efficient when it matters. The result is a 35-45% energy yield gain! Much more that fixed carports. Our canopies are prefabricated reducing on-site installation/labor costs by 95%. We use a crane to install the canopy in a couple of hours.The canopy offers a waterproof option and can sustain winds up to 130MPH. O&M costs are minimal, and the system is remote controlled. It is an elegant structure, the motor is small and the entire structure presents absolutely no danger to humans. We would be happy to share more information with you if you desire. Check out our website in the meantime. Thank you.
its a nice car parking structure right here! which company fabricated such car park design ?
Hi Ghaith, I’m afraid that image was taken from Flickr so I can’t tell you which company was responsible. Maybe one of our readers could help?
Increasing demand from energy and power industry is one of the factor which is anticipated to drive the demand of Solar Battery Charger. Access Sample Pages of Solar Battery Charger Market @ https://cutt.us/XivjH .
During 2017, the individual consumer segment dominated the market with a market share of around 60%. Factors like the augmented usage of electronic devices and an increase in the time spent outdoors will bolster the growth of this market segment over the forecast period. Moreover, the increasing need for reliable chargers that do not depend on the main power supply will aid in the growth of this market segment.
The report features market size, share, growth factors, challenges, demand & top players’ analysis.
Here in Australia we are having some incredible solar car parks built and plugged back into the grid. Utilising the sun as a valued renewable resource is a long time coming here in Australia, but hopefully more projects like this one https://pvstructures.com.au/latest-projects/solar-carpark-leichhardt-market-place/ will be built to further utilise solar power in a country that has so much sunshine.